How could Ilan Ramon’s Diary Survive the Fall from Space?

Payload specialist Ilan Ramon

A little while ago, the Israeli Museum in Jerusalem opened an exhibit featuring some of the torn, slightly burned pages of Col. Ilan Ramon‘s personal diary from the shuttle Columbia. Ramon was the payload specialist onboard STS-107 (the spaceshuttle “Columbia”) that disintegrated during re-entry from space, killing all 7 crewmembers onboard. The diary survived the re-entry and subsequent crash, and was found in a field next to Palestine, TX.

Ramon’s personal diary fell close to 37 miles (almost 60 km) through the extreme conditions of re-entry. Unlike its human owner, it has survived the process and is now being restored and presented to the public in the Israeli Museum in Jerusalem.

During the weeks and months after the Columbia disaster, pieces of the debris were still being collected from wide areas in Texas. small pieces of insulation that detached from the outer parts of the shuttle to pieces of the Astronauts’ space suits. In an article covering the subject on “Universe Today”, The Israeli Museum curator is quoted as saying that “There is no rational explanation for how it was recovered when most of the shuttle was not.” It is no wonder, then, that many are awe-struck at such an apparent miracle.

But is there, really, no rational explanation for the survival of the diary? None at all? I doubt that. And when I doubt, I check it out, which is exactly what I am about to do.

A thought (or two) about Hypotheses

The information about the Columbia disaster is available in many online and offline sources, but it is still very limited. We can guesstimate what happened to certain parts of the shuttle based on facts on the ground and what we already know from previous manned missions to space using the Columbia shuttle.

The general investigation I am about to embark on in this post is based on the material I have found online and my own personal knowledge, strengthened by facts from other missions and physical concepts. It is by no means complete, and I had no time (or resources, sadly) to do a full blown investigation into the full train of events that Col. Ramon’s diary went through. If you have any thoughts on the matter, or if you hold any factual data that will help hypothesize what it “went through” in the moments before hitting the ground, please share them in the comment section. I am very much willing to update and upgrade this hypothesis in light of new information or ideas (just make sure you base those on valid data, of course).

I try to support my guesstimates with valid data when I can, and use ‘extremes’ to get us a rough idea of how this discovery (and this ‘survival’ of such an item) is possible.

The Space Shuttle – Crew Quarters

The space shuttle is built to sustain its crew for days (and sometimes weeks) in space. It has sleeping bunks, restroom and shower, all located in the crew area in the “Mid Deck” (picture is taken from Space Shuttle News Reference (NASA), p 5-5):

According to ex-astronaut R. Mike Mullane, the mid deck also holds the crew personal lockers (“Do Your Ears Pop in Space”, R.  Mike Mullane, pg 135). We will remember this fact when we consider the process in which the Columbia disintegrated (keep reading).

Where was the Diary Located?

No one can know for sure (at least not from the published data that I’ve read) where the diary was located before the Columbia’s disastrous descent. However, there are a few facts we can be sure of:

  • The crew was about to come home; their personal items were, most likely, locked away in their personal lockers, that are located in the Mid Deck.
  • According to astronauts who were active in previous missions, a diary is sometimes put in the lower pocket of the flight suit. If the diary wasn’t locked away in Ramon’s personal locker, it is logical it was safely tucked into his flight suit pocket.  Flight suits are very durable and tolerate extreme heat and cold conditions.

Either way, it seems logical to assume that the diary was placed somewhere that kept it safe from the initial processes of re-entry and descent.

Temperature Variation

Unlike common belief, the intense heat on the wings and body of a space shuttle as it descends from Space is not caused by friction, but rather by ‘compression’. The big body of the shuttle compresses air molecules downwards so strongly that the air around the shuttle becomes dense and packed like plasma. At this point, the wing-edge temperature naturally rise, and can reach a temperature of about 1,400° Celcius (2,500° Fahrenheit).

After the initial temperature rises, the Columbia initiated a roll to the right, a maneuver that decreases its speed and the heat on its body. This maneuver was successfully performed, and following it were 10 minutes where the heat on the body of the shuttle reached its peak. From there, it started to cool down.

The temperature at these heights is extremely low, and the heat from the shuttle can dissipate relatively quickly.

Explosion vs. Disintegration

About 15 minutes after the Columbia entered the Earth’s atmosphere, pieces of debris were visibly shedding out of its body. But the Columbia did not explode, it disintegrated, and this difference is very important to understand what happened to the parts inside the shuttle.

Explosion and Disintegration are two very different processes.

Explosion is quick and “dirty”, resulting in a lot of damage to the individual parts. Disintegration is the breaking apart of the whole into individual, smaller, parts. It is usually slower, and gradual. The Columbia’s disintegration began about 10 minutes after re-entry and lasted until the massive body crashed on the surface. The various parts and debris were scattered over an enormous area, from eastern Texas to Western Louisiana.

The fact that the Columbia disintegrated, rather than exploded, has two main meanings for our investigation:

  1. The Columbia did not ‘explode’ all at once; it took time for the various parts to separate away from the main body while the shuttle was cooling down in descent.
  2. In an explosion, the parts heat up due to the exerted energy. When a body disintegrates, the parts separate away from the body without experiencing any sort of extra heat. If a piece was deep inside the shuttle, it wasn’t subjected for the intense heat from the plasma (during re entry). It would take it longer to be thrown-away and out of the body of the shuttle. It would, therefore, “spend” less time free-falling.

The objects inside the Columbia slowly broke apart and began a gradual free-fall to the ground, from varying heights, the largest of which is approximately 60 km above the surface of the Earth.

Disintegration = Change in Shape

The shuttle is designed and built for aerodynamic movement. From the nose, to the wings and tail, the purpose is to make sure its movement in the air is smooth and with as little drag as possible. This is meant to decrease drag and allow the pilot better control over the movement of the shuttle once it’s back inside the atmosphere.

Aerodynamic objects move very quickly through the air because of their shape. But Columbia began disintegrating about 40 minutes after initiating the ‘de-orbiting’ maneuver. Parts tore off its body, probably starting with the wings and tail (that ‘stick out’ of the body and are subjected to more heat and pressures). Once those pieces – and pieces of the outer hull – tore off, the Columbia lost its aerodynamic shape. From this point on, it will slow down dramatically.

Terminal Velocity of an Object

In reality, when an object falls from a certain height down to the ground, its velocity increases because of the pull of gravity. Air resistance, however, exerts a force upwards – “fighting” the downward acceleration. When both forces are equal, they both negate one another, and the object falls in a constant speed (without the effect of any acceleration). That speed is called ‘terminal velocity‘.

For example, a sky diver falling from 12,000 feet would stop accelerating (hence, would move at a constant speed) at about 200 kph (124 mph). If his parachute didn’t open, he would hit the ground at the same force that a motorcyclist going at 200kph would hit a cement wall in case of a head-on collision (don’t try this at home). The height, in the case of the speeding diary, is not a very good indicator as to the force it hit the ground with.

Terminal Velocity and the Falling Diary

Assuming the diary was protected during the initial stages of the disastrous descent (as I’ve already explained), it shouldn’t have fallen as fast as it may sound like. When we hear the height “60 km above ground”, it sounds as if the falling object would hit the ground at enormous speed (and force). That, however, isn’t the case, because of the terminal velocity.

It is very much possible that the diary was packed or partially protected during parts of the fall, stopped accelerating at the terminal velocity. The pieces continued to disintegrate as they fell, and at some point whatever ‘protected’ the diary disintegrated and exposed it to the full force of the fall. But by that time the conditions that existed at the beginning of the fall were considerably lessened.

Conclusion

  • Based on past missions and the structure of the Space Shuttle, we can safely assume the diary was encapsulated inside an item that protected it, either a closed locker or a sealed space suit pocket.
  • Air resistance (and the laws of physics) makes the speed of falling objects limited.
  • The diary was found in a damp field covered with soft leafs (provided a relatively soft landing).
  • Other pieces of debris survived the long extreme fall to Earth (see next section).

Based on all the above, it is a bit easier to see a logical trail of events that could lead to the survival of a paper diary. This isn’t a miracle; it’s a surviving piece of history in light of a horrible, disastrous space mission.

A bit of Realism (Other objects made it, too..)

So we’ve examined the situation, and saw that it’s not as unlikely as we might have first thought for such an item to survive the Columbia disaster. A lot of other debris have survived, including ‘sensitive’ materials such as CPU boards and pieces of cloth from the astronauts’ uniforms and rest area. But we also need to take into account the condition in which the diary was found.

According to the State of Israel Ministry of Public Security, which was responsible for the reconstruction and preservation of these pages, the diary was very hard to decipher. It was found wet, torn and crumpled in a muddy field (see picture). The efforts involved a lot of digitized reconstruction along with some measure of guesswork. Some of the text on the pages was simply incomprehensible.

That said, it is also important to remember that this is not the most “surprising” piece of debris that “survived” re-entry. If you want surprise, it is reported that a few worms survived re-entry and the fall to Earth. Yes, alive. A piece of crumpled, wet, torn paper, as emotional and touching as it may be (and I agree that it is), is hardly any competition to life forms surviving the fall to Earth.

This is no miracle.

Many thanks to Capn_Refsmmat for (again!) being the brevity King, and for asking questions that needed to be answered.

References and Resources

Related articles

30 comments
lonsemaryrose
lonsemaryrose

click to view to your friends and get big save

Brerawagele
Brerawagele

Hi amazing thread you have going there.

ForumJoBa
ForumJoBa

Hello, I am new on this forum... Glad to see you all

My name is Ferio Larco. Living in California. Would like to find here new friends and to speak a bit about main topic:))

dalexwestfall
dalexwestfall

I am new here and at the same time immediately i only want to say hi there to All Ms and Mr

pandora charms
pandora charms

Hello Every one ,

Irrrm new here.

Glad in order to you here.

I would really prefer to share with and study on all of you.

Say thank you advanced.

stephJennn
stephJennn

Hii! Now joining, glad to be in! I glimpse forward to partcipating and have read a great deal so far, so hello!

Sooo anyways, sufficient info about me, see you close to and hello once again haha.

BTW, what can I do to get emails sent to me if there is a reply? I just got a new phone, so it would be very helpful for me. Amazing how even a trainer needs so many electronics now!

Zefunsusiafus
Zefunsusiafus

Any coin collectors here have a coin value book to estimate what an MS64 1925-S Gaudens gold is priced at?

software_man
software_man

If you multipost an image, the image link in all of the posts will associate with the Twitter account that you designate as your default. That could pose a problem if you want to keep your Twitter accounts separate (as I do). To choose your default account, selectMenu, Accounts and long-press the one you want to use.

AssangePap
AssangePap

So..... where is toilet? Hehe))) Joke, relax ;)

Hope for answer

bye bye ;))

Lorencokal
Lorencokal

So..... where is toilet? Hehe))) Joke, relax ;)

Thank you

DaSSuka
DaSSuka

O.K so i hv to make blackjack game in c++ i can use do-while loop int cout string char etc..anyone know how to make black jack game in XCODE? plz help me thanks...

___________________

Dentysta

OnenJetry
OnenJetry

Hello! Everyone I need your help. From previous months, I have been able to play cabal online with norton antivirus on at my Windows Vista and Windows Xp computer. But recently, after norton has been updated, I can n o longer load my cabal online game. Any tips how I can solve this? I am looking for step by step procedure on how I can make my computer able to load cabal online once again. Thank you very much in advance.

_______________

Transport pneumatyczny

portman
portman

Online pharmacies offer the most opportune conditions in the course of the liberation and payment of ED Pills. Ordered ED Pills may be delivered by courier or near post, and at the unchanging time nowhere on the packaging longing not bespeak what's inside.

Doraancen
Doraancen

Hi I just registered to this great place www.smarterthanthat.com . I want to ask for your opinion.

Can you tell me please do you trade forex and if yes what forex dealer do you use?

Do you know of some good ones?

Thanks in advance for your answers.

P.S. Sorry if I have posted to wrong section this but as you can see I am new here.

Catherine Michael
Catherine Michael

Wow,

What a nice post,i just found this post story from my technorati profile news feeds section! I was searching for this since past 3 months and i am glad to see it here. Thanking you much

Kathe

Michael Jane
Michael Jane

Hi

Fantastic information,This is the first time i heard about this. keep it up this good works.

Regards,

William

jayrtfm
jayrtfm

>>the purpose is to make sure its movement in the air is smooth and with as little drag as possible.

err, not quite.

During most of its descent it comes in belly first, to give it the most drag so it can slow down.

It is designed to avoid turbulence.

Only when it is in the lower atmosphere does it start flying like a normal airplane.

mooeypoo
mooeypoo

@jayrtfm,

You're absolutely right. In the article, I meant the movement at a bit lower heights, seeing as the Columbia made the "roll" and maneuver that transforms it from high-drag position to more of an airplane-like position.

But I completely accept, you're right, this depends on what height - the first stage is the increase the drag and to get the shuttle to slow down.

Thank you for the comment!

BryanLower
BryanLower

This was very well written and informative. Thank you.

-B

«bønez_brigade»
«bønez_brigade»

Well done. However, I must take issue with the following line:

"... it’s a surviving piece of history in light of a horrible, disastrous space mission."

The mission itself was _not_ disastrous. In fact, it was quite productive whilst on-orbit. The EDL part -- _that_ was disastrous; and launch could possibly be included, as that's where it started. I'm sure you didn't mean it that way, but that's how it reads. Other than that criticism, your rational review of it was a good read.

mooeypoo
mooeypoo

Thank you :)

You're absolutely right, and to be honest, I noticed this after posting. I meant that the ending was disastrous; the mission itself wasn't. It might be better phrased as ".. it's a surviving piece of history in light of a horrible, disastrous *END* of this space mission".

Actually, I think that even out of the pieces that survived (some hard drives, the [live] worms, etc) it was possible to extract very useful information about the experiments that were conducted while in orbit.. I will have to look it up, though, it might make for a great post, examining the benefits of the experiments that were done in orbit with the STS-107.

I'll think of a better way of phrasing it and will change it in the post - I didn't really mean to say the entire mission was a disaster. Thanks for pointing this out to me :)

Trackbacks

  1. […] usually like to keep things light on Fridays, but this is too good to keep until Monday. Moriel Schotttlander has written up an account of how the Shuttle Columbia astronaut Ilan Ramon’s personal diary survived (more or less) the […]

  2. […] How could Ilan Ramon’s Diary Survive the Fall from Space? — Fascinating. (Hat tip to Bad Astronomy Blog.) […]

Astronomy

We’re SmarterThanThat

The scientific method is all around you, and you use it without even noticing. Science can be fun, interesting and engaging; you don't have to be a nerd to enjoy understanding the world around you. Read More...

I’m on Facebook!

Get it to your Email!

Get the RSS Feed to your email when new posts are available!

FBFPowered by ®Google Feedburner